Cheese Savoury Sandwich Filling – A North East classic sandwich filling from England and one that was made famous by Gregg’s the Bakers

Perfect for a Stottie/Stotty Cake Sandwich

Today’s recipe for Cheese Savoury Sandwich Filling, is an updated recipe from a few years ago, here: Stotty Cakes & Geordie Ploughman’s Lunches! Cheese Savoury (Sandwich Filling) Recipe.
Much though I love that recipe, I recently came upon a recipe in the back of an old BeRo cookbook, that was my late mother’s book, with a slightly different recipe.

Instead of red onion, which I must admit is something my nanny or mum never used a lot, if ever, the onions suggested in this recipe, were spring onions (scallions)
Furthermore, mayonnaise was not mentioned, not that I used it in my other recipe, and salad cream was the binding agent in the recipe I found, which makes sense, given the era.

My grandparents never used mayonnaise, as I remember – it was always salad cream that adorned simple, seasonal salads, as well as boiled eggs and potato salad.
This updated recipe for cheese savoury is fabulous, with a lovely thick and creamy consistency and a really tangy flavour.

It’s also a great way of sneaking some vegetables into your little one’s lunch box, if you make sandwiches with this filling.
My favourite sandwich is cheese and onion, so this has my name all over it, plus this has grated carrot in it, resulting in a really delicious vegetarian sandwich filling.

I recently came back from Northumberland and County Duham, where we had a wonderful week’s holiday, and on my return, I made some Stottie Cakes, and a batch of cheese savoury to fill them with.
This sandwich filling is easy to make, and is fabulous when served in jacket potatoes, and on toast, in the manner of a cheat’s Welsh Rarebit.

Notes:
- A North Eastern classic sandwich filling from England and one that was made famous by Gregg’s the Bakers of Gosforth in Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
- Traditionally used to fill “stotty/stottie cake” sandwiches, this is a fabulous vegetarian spread for the school or office lunch box.
- The filling is also perfect for picnics, suppers, high tea and cricket teas too.
- Once made, it will keep in the fridge for nearly a week, if it lasts that long, and it is also great when spread on toast.

More Recipes from North East England



- Panackelty – Store Cupboard Hot-Pot
- A Country Recipe: Winter Salad (Pickle)
- Country Cottage Comfort Food: Nanny’s Pan Haggerty



- Carlins, Black Badgers and Parched Peas
- Stotty Cakes & Geordie Ploughman’s Lunches! Cheese Savoury (Sandwich Filling) Recipe
- Yorkshire Salad aka Durham Salad or Mint Salad



Cheese Savoury Sandwich Filling Recipe
Cheese Savoury Sandwich Filling
Today's recipe for Cheese Savoury Sandwich Filling, is an updated recipe from a few years ago, here: Stotty Cakes & Geordie Ploughman’s Lunches! Cheese Savoury (Sandwich Filling) Recipe.
Much though I love that recipe, I recently came upon a recipe in the back of an old BeRo cookbook, that was my late mother's book, with a slightly different recipe.
Instead of red onion, which I must admit is something my nanny or mum never used a lot, if ever, the onions suggested in this recipe, were spring onions (scallions)
Furthermore, mayonnaise was not mentioned, not that I used it in my other recipe, and salad cream was the binding agent in the recipe I found, which makes sense, given the era.
My grandparents never used mayonnaise, as I remember - it was always salad cream that adorned simple, seasonal salads, as well as boiled eggs and potato salad.
This updated recipe for cheese savoury is fabulous, with a lovely thick and creamy consistency and a really tangy flavour.
It’s also a great way of sneaking some vegetables into your little one’s lunch box, if you make sandwiches with this filling.
My favourite sandwich is cheese and onion, so this has my name all over it, plus this has grated carrot in it, resulting in a really delicious vegetarian sandwich filling.
I recently came back from Northumberland and County Duham, where we had a wonderful week's holiday, and on my return, I made some Stottie Cakes, and a batch of cheese savoury to fill them with.
This sandwich filling is easy to make, and is fabulous when served in jacket potatoes, and on toast, in the manner of a cheat's Welsh Rarebit.
Ingredients
- 250g grated extra mature or vintage Cheddar cheese
- 1 large carrot, peeled and grated
- 1 bunch of spring onions (scallions) trimmed and very finely diced
- salad cream
- salt and pepper to taste
Instructions
- Mix the grated cheese, carrot and diced spring onions in a bowl and then add salad cream spoon by spoon, until a spreadable and creamy consistency has been achieved.
- Adjust seasoning with salt and pepper and leave for at least 4 hours in the fridge before using. Keeps for up to 4 to 5 days in a covered container in the fridge.
- Makes 8 rounds of sandwiches, 4 x quarters of Stottie/Stotty cake, or 8 bread rolls.
Notes
A North Eastern classic sandwich filling from England and one that was made famous by Gregg's the Bakers of Gosforth in Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
Traditionally used to fill "stotty/stottie cake" sandwiches, this is a fabulous vegetarian spread for the school or office lunch box.
The filling is also perfect for picnics, suppers, high tea and cricket teas too.
Once made, it will keep in the fridge for nearly a week, if it lasts that long, and it is also great when spread on toast.
Nutrition Information
Yield 8 Serving Size 1Amount Per Serving Calories 134Total Fat 11gSaturated Fat 6gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 4gCholesterol 31mgSodium 256mgCarbohydrates 2gFiber 0gSugar 1gProtein 7g








Cath Laing says
I just love you recipes!!
Karen Burns-Booth says
Thank you so much
Judy L says
I’ll need to improvise the salad cream. Is there any sweetness to it? Ive read that it’s thinner than mayo with vinegar perhaps?
Ron/Brisbane says
Hi Karen –
Australian fan of L&L here!
Had a bunch of leftover cheeses after friends came around the other day – and had carrots and spring onions – so made up a batch.
Didn’t have salad cream to hand – it’s not as common in Oz – don’t think I’ve ever tried it! – but this was delicious made using my favourite commercial mayo.
Will definitely be making again – reminded me a lot of an old favourite sandwich filling from a health food chain here in Sydney in the 80s – only their version was nutmeat and carrot – and it was equally delicious (I might try and replicate it – this has inspired me! Know it sounds unappealing but it had the same sort of texture and the savoury nutmeat with the sweet carrot worked so well!)
My only word of advice to anyone making the cheese and carrot version is to not add any salt until after it’s all mixed and ready to taste as the cheese can be salty – as can the mayo (and assume commercial salad cream has similar sodium levels as commercial mayonnaise?) – and felt I’d overdone it just slightly.
Anyway – thank you for unearthing all these wonderful old recipes and encouraging us all to rediscover so many lost gems!
Karen Burns-Booth says
Hi there Ron
THANK YOU so much for your great comments, and tips for other readers too 🙂
It’s lovely to hear from you, as a reader, and I appreciate you taking the time to leave such a long and helpful comment.
I am so pleased you are a L & L fan!!
More recipes coming up that I hope you will like.
Cheers,
Karen