• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Karen
    • PR & Disclosure
    • Press and As Seen In…
    • Privacy Policy
  • Freelance
    • Work with Me
    • Recipe Development
    • Travel With Me
  • Recipe Box
    • Baking
    • Dairy
    • Dessert
    • Fish
    • General
    • Meat
    • Preserves
    • Seasonal Recipes
    • Snacks
    • Vegetarian
  • Kitchen Tips
  • Travel
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australasia
    • Europe
    • North America
    • South America
  • Book
  • Contact
Lavender and Lovage header graphic

Lavender and Lovage

You are here: Home / Featured / Slider / Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets

22 September 2019 By Karen Burns-Booth 8 Comments

Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets

Yum

Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets – A lovely tangy and piquant Welsh rarebit mixture that is perfect when spread and melted on toasted crumpets. Serve for breakfast, brunch or supper with grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and crispy bacon. The mixture can be made ahead and lasts for five days in the fridge…..

Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets

…..and other Autumn Fireside Supper Recipes

A lovely tangy and piquant Welsh rarebit mixture that is perfect when spread and melted on toasted crumpets. Serve for breakfast, brunch or supper with grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and crispy bacon. The mixture can be made ahead and lasts for five days in the fridge.

September is the start of the season of mists and mellow fruitfulness, it seems like one minute we are enjoying the last rays of late summer, and then almost to the start of the month, I’m seeing swirling mists over the mountains opposite me, and there’s a definite “nip in the air” in the early morning and evenings. When I venture out into the garden, I can smell the aromatic scent of wood smoke, as well as the heavy aroma of rotten windfalls in the orchard, almost like a tannin rich wine, they lay on the dew-soaked grass and provide food for insects and our resident blackbirds. We’ve not actually lit a fire yet, as we have enjoyed a bit of an Indian summer of late, but I’m already thinking of fireside suppers and other cold weather recipes. Today’s recipe for Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets is just the sort of recipe that I envisage enjoying in front of a roaring fire, easy to make, it has comfort food written all over it, although it’s one of the most popular breakfast requests in our B and B. 

B and B Welsh Rarebit

Welsh rarebit on crumpets

I always associate a good Welsh Rarebit, or Rabbit as it should be called, with tea time and evenings, as the recipe contains ale in it, although not a lot, and it is more of a “slow snack” that needs to be enjoyed when time isn’t at a premium, as it may be at lunch time. The first Welsh Rabbit recipe as seen in print was back in 1725, although another version, for what we now know as Welsh Rarebit, was seen sixty years later in 1785; there were many “rabbit” recipes about, and the 18th century cookery writer, Hannah Glasse, offered several recipes for a rabbit, from Wales, Scotland and England. It seems that a Welsh rabbit had mustard added whilst an English rabbit had ale or red wine added, so today’s recipe is both English and Welsh, as I have added mustard and ale to the mix.* *(You can add milk in place of ale if you wish) 

I always associate a good Welsh Rarebit, or Rabbit as it should be called, with tea time and evenings, as the recipe contains ale in it, although not a lot, and it is more of a "slow snack" that needs to be enjoyed when time isn't at a premium, as it may be at lunch time. The first Welsh Rabbit recipe as seen in print, was way back in 1725, although another version, for what we now know as Welsh Rarebit was seen sixty years later in 1785; there were many "rabbit" recipes about, and the 18th century cookery writer, Hannah Glasse, offered several recipes for a rabbit, from Wales, Scotland and England. It seems that a Welsh rabbit had mustard added whilst an English rabbit had ale or red wine added, so the recipe below is both English and Welsh, as I have added mustard and ale to the mix. This is mum and grandmother’s family recipe, and in my opinion, it is the best.

I always associate a good Welsh Rarebit, or Rabbit as it should be called, with tea time and evenings, as the recipe contains ale in it, although not a lot, and it is more of a "slow snack" that needs to be enjoyed when time isn't at a premium, as it may be at lunch time. The first Welsh Rabbit recipe as seen in print, was way back in 1725, although another version, for what we now know as Welsh Rarebit was seen sixty years later in 1785; there were many "rabbit" recipes about, and the 18th century cookery writer, Hannah Glasse, offered several recipes for a rabbit, from Wales, Scotland and England. It seems that a Welsh rabbit had mustard added whilst an English rabbit had ale or red wine added, so the recipe below is both English and Welsh, as I have added mustard and ale to the mix. This is mum and grandmother’s family recipe, and in my opinion, it is the best.

Today’s recipe is a new rarebit recipe, one that I make for our B and B guests as part of our cooked breakfast choice….it’s not strictly a traditional rarebit mixture, as it contains eggs, but I need the eggs to act as a setting and stabilising agent for the mixture, so it’s well behaved and sits on top of the toasted crumpets, rather than running away! I have a few other rarebit recipes on Lavender and Lovage, as well as my mum and grandma’s recipe in my book. It’s a really lovely tangy and piquant Welsh rarebit mixture,. which is perfect when spread and melted on top of toasted crumpets. Great for breakfast, brunch or supper, and lovely with grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and crispy bacon. The mixture can be made ahead and lasts for five days in the fridge, which makes it a doddle for busy mornings, so as well as being a fabulous fireside supper dish, it’s a recipe that would work really well for mid-week breakfasts, for the children before they go to school.

Cheese on Crumpets

Welsh Rarebit

This delicious recipe for Welsh Rarebit on Crumpets is shared below, and so try to used toasted crumpets as the vehicle for the cheesy mixture, it’s a great alternative to the usual toasted bread. Have a relaxing and fun weekend,

Karen 

Welsh Rarebit on Toasted Crumpets

Print recipe
  • Print with main photo
  • Print text only
Welsh Rarebit on Toasted Crumpets
Serves 8 Crumpets
Prep time 20 minutes
Cook time 15 minutes
Total time 35 minutes
Allergy Egg, Milk, Wheat
Dietary Vegetarian
Meal type Breakfast, Lunch, Side Dish, Snack
Misc Child Friendly, Pre-preparable, Serve Hot
Occasion Christmas, Easter, Thanksgiving
Region British
By author Karen Burns-Booth
A lovely tangy and piquant Welsh rarebit mixture that is perfect when spread and melted on toasted crumpets. Serve for breakfast, brunch or supper with grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and crispy bacon. The mixture can be made ahead and lasts for five days in the fridge.

Ingredients

  • 225g grated extra mature Cheddar cheese
  • 2 large free-range eggs (beaten)
  • 150ml full cream milk (or 150ml beer, such as pale ale or IPA)
  • 1 heaped teaspoon ready-made English mustard
  • 10 splashes of Worcestershire Sauce
  • salt and pepper, to taste
  • 1 tablespoon cornflour (mixed with a little milk or beer)
  • Crumpets (toasted and buttered)
  • Snipped fresh chives and parsley (to serve)

Note

A lovely tangy and piquant Welsh rarebit mixture that is perfect when spread and melted on toasted crumpets. Serve for breakfast, brunch or supper with grilled tomatoes, mushrooms and crispy bacon. The mixture can be made ahead and lasts for five days in the fridge.

Directions

Step 1 Mix the first six ingredients together until smooth. Spoon or pour into a saucepan and heat gently until the cheese has melted, and the mixture is thick but still fairly runny. Add the cornflour mixture and heat until thickened. Take off the heat and allow to cool, the mixture will set as it cools and become stiff. At this stage, you can store it in a covered container in the fridge for up to five days.
Step 2 Once the mixture has been made and cooked, toast the crumpets and then butter them. Set them on a lined baking tray or in a grill, and spoon and spread some of the mixture over the top, spreading it quite thickly.
Step 3 Place the covered crumpets under a pre-heated grill and grill until the cheese mixture has browned and is bubbling.
Step 4 Serve straight away with snipped fresh chives and parsley scattered over the Welsh Rarebit Toasted Crumpets. Great with grilled tomatoes and mushrooms, as well as crispy bacon.
Step 5 NB: This mixture is enough to cover 8 crumpets. Not suitable for freezing but keeps in the fridge for up to five days.

More Autumn Fireside Supper Recipes

Slow Sunday Brunch:

Welsh Rabbit with Home-made Rustic French Boule (Bread)

Slow Sunday Brunch: Welsh Rabbit with Home-made Rustic French Boule (Bread)

Smoked Cheese and Cherry Tomato Rarebit:

On Toast Snack or Light Supper Recipe

Smoked Cheese and Cherry Tomato Rarebit: On Toast Snack or Light Supper Recipe

Welsh Rarebit Cheese Spread

Welsh Rarebit Cheese Spread

Autumn Suppers:

Bonfire Chilli with Beef, Chocolate and Pumpkin

Organic October and Autumn Suppers: Bonfire Chilli with Beef, Chocolate and Pumpkin

Christmas Eve Fireside Supper Chicken & Ham Pie

A delectable and hearty pie which is perfect for a cosy Christmas Eve fireside supper, especially when served with a glass of chilled Provence Rosé wine.

Ski Chalet Supper:

Tartiflette Savoyarde with Reblochon Cheese

Ski Chalet Supper: Tartiflette Savoyarde with Reblochon Cheese

Meal Planning Monday and Cheesy Stuffed Supper Spuds

(Baked Jacket Potatoes) Recipe

Cheesy Stuffed Supper Spuds (Baked Jacket Potatoes)

Mum’s Cheese and Potato Pie for Family Suppers

Mum's Cheese and Potato Pie

Welsh Cawl (Lamb & Vegetable Stew)

Welsh Cawl

Grana Padano Chicken & Artichoke Gratin

Grana Padano Chicken & Artichoke Gratin

Healthy Cauliflower Cheese

Healthy Cauliflower Cheese

Related Posts

  • Welsh Rarebit Cheese Spread
    Welsh Rarebit Cheese Spread
  • Smoked Cheese and Cherry Tomato Rarebit: On Toast Snack or Light Supper Recipe
    Smoked Cheese and Cherry Tomato Rarebit: On Toast Snack or Light Supper Recipe
  • Marinated English Goat’s Cheese with Garlic, Stem Ginger and Herbs
    Herbs on Saturday: Marinated English Goat’s Cheese with Wild Garlic, Stem Ginger and Herbs
  • Mini Cheese, Cranberry and Walnut Scones Recipe
    Day Five on the Advent Calendar and Mini Cheese, Cranberry and Walnut Scones Recipe

Filed Under: All Year Recipes, Breakfast, Brunch, Cheese, Eggs, On Toast, Slider, Vegetarian Tagged With: B and B breakfast, Cheddar Cheese, comfort food, Crumpets, Fireside, Supper, Toasted Crumpets, Welsh Rabbit, Welsh Rarebit

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jayne says

    22 September 2019 at 12:44 pm

    Planning a day out with friends on a boat around the islands tomorrow, and was just wondering if I had something in the fridge that I could throw together for a quick supper when we get back (Captain Apo always makes us a wonderful lunch, so only a snack required). You’ve just provided the perfect answer. It will have to be made with Turkish Bergama cheese and a drop of Efes lager, but I am sure it will be just as good, if a little different to the original – and I even have English mustard and Worcester sauce in the cupboard – hurrah. And homemade English muffins (already languishing in the freezer) in lieu of the crumpets. Yummy. I can see this being a frequent request by Himself.

    Reply
    • Karen Burns-Booth says

      22 September 2019 at 4:35 pm

      That sounds absolutely spot on Jayne! And having lived in N Cyprus for a while, I LOVE Efes beer!
      Please do let me know how it all turns out for you, Karen 🙂

      Reply
      • Jayne says

        7 October 2019 at 10:13 am

        They were totally and utterly yummy – I thought I’d made enough of the topping for two goes, but we had friends here and the whole lot got snaffled. Definitely going to become a regular snack in this household. When we get back to Cornwall, I will try them with traditional Cheddar. Thank you for sharing your lovely recipes.

        Reply
  2. sherry says

    2 October 2019 at 10:32 pm

    mum used to make us this for a quick dinner sometimes. it was always called Rabbit:) we loved the name too. i’ve not had it in years so i must give it a go soon. cheers sherry

    Reply
    • Karen Burns-Booth says

      4 October 2019 at 10:01 am

      Yes, it can also be called Rabbit here in the UK too! It’s such a LOVELY dish isn’t it? Karen 🙂

      Reply
  3. sherry says

    2 October 2019 at 10:33 pm

    oh dear my comment vanished. just saying i must give this a go soon. cheers sherry

    Reply
    • Karen Burns-Booth says

      4 October 2019 at 10:01 am

      It is here! Thanks for commenting again! Karen

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recipe & Ingredient Search

Follow

  • Bloglovin
  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Meet Karen

Welcome! I'm Karen; it’s lovely to see you here. I was born in South Africa, but I've lived all over the world, latterly calling North Yorkshire my home where I lived for many years before moving to SW France, although I'm now living in the Lincolnshire Wolds, a designated area of outstanding natural beauty, in an old Victorian cottage. I am a freelance food and travel writer, as well as a food stylist, and recipe developer, with a passion for art, travel, books, photography, seasonal food and especially cheese and wine. Please do get in contact with me if you have any questions about my work or commissioning me. Read More…

Buy my Book & Tea Towels

Lavender and Lovage Book

Born from her eponymous award winning blog this book contains 160 unique recipes, all beautifully photographed by the author. They showcase the breadth and depth of her travel. Karen has lived and travelled all over the world and has brought some of her favourite recipes, experiences, and memories to share here with her readers. Buy my Book HERE

Search Categories

Easy to Access Archives

Top Blog 2025

VuelioTop10Badge2025

Top Blog 2024

VuelioTop10Badge2024

Top Blog 2023

VuelioTop10Badge2023

Top 10 Blog 2022

VuelioTop10Badge2022

Top 10 Blog 2021

VuelioTop10Badge2021

Top 10 Blog 2020

VuelioTop10Badge2020

Copyright Lavender and Lovage © 2026
Website built by Callia Web
Linocut designs by Callie Jones